Launched by the ABPI’s Dispute Resolution Center, the SMOD-CDD offers an independent, fully online second layer for reviewing platform content-moderation decisions, combining intellectual property, privacy and digital rights expertise within Brazil’s platform-liability framework.
The last decade has fundamentally changed how legal disputes are born. The internet stopped being a collection of static pages and became an ecosystem of continuous, user-driven production, in which anyone can publish, replicate and monetize content in seconds, often without any meaningful editorial control.
Generative tools have accelerated this process to the point where the volume of material circulating online can no longer be inspected by human reviewers, and the consequences spill directly into the legal domain: takedown orders, counterfeit products sold through marketplaces, unauthorized uses of trademarks and protected assets, deepfakes built on someone’s name, image or voice. These conflicts are no longer occasional; they are generated by the thousand every day, and the traditional dispute-resolution machinery, built around the rhythm of physical files and in-person hearings, was never designed to absorb them. The question is no longer whether online disputes exist, but who is institutionally prepared to resolve them with the speed, specialization and legitimacy they demand.
That question has pushed content moderation to the center of the most intense debates on the responsibility of digital actors. In the European Union, the Digital Services Act turned moderation into a matter of regulatory due diligence, imposing transparency obligations and enforcement that has already produced landmark fines, including the €120 million penalty applied to platform X in December 2025 for DSA violations.
In the United States, the longstanding immunity of Section 230 has come under sustained attack from both sides of the political spectrum, while observers describe how the DSA’s standards are exporting themselves worldwide through the so-called Brussels effect (thesis that the EU, by promulgating regulations that govern the international business environment and lead to the Europeanization of many important aspects of global commerce and shapes policy in areas such as online hate speech and data privacy, among others).
In all cases, the underlying tension is always the same: platforms have become private regulators by default, deciding what stays and what disappears, yet their decisions are opaque, algorithmically driven and hard to challenge.
Brazil has also entered this debate. In June 2025, the Supreme Federal Court ruled that Article 19 of the Civil Rights Framework for the Internet is partially unconstitutional, opening the door to platform liability for illegal user content even without a prior judicial removal order. This decision, however, has been described as a battle won in a war far from over and its practical consequences continue to be processed by scholarship and the courts.
Even if approved, the “Fake News Bill” (PL 2630/2020) would leave a regulatory vacuum, and with it the unresolved question of who decides, with what criteria and under what procedural guarantees, what may remain online. Implementation, in turn, faces structural obstacles: the sheer scale of moderation decisions, the opacity of ranking and removal algorithms, the risk of over-removal to avoid liability, and the absence of genuinely independent reviewing bodies with the technical capacity to assess trademark, privacy and personality-rights claims in context. Due process, in the digital environment, is still largely a promise without an institution to honor it.
The mechanism launched by the Dispute Resolution Center of the Brazilian Intellectual Property Association (ABPI) seeks to address this question. Through its Chamber for the Resolution of Disputes Relating to Digital Law (CDD-ABPI), the Center presented the SMOD-CDD — the Online Dispute Moderation System — an extrajudicial, fully online dispute resolution (ODR) mechanism designed for the specialized analysis of conflicts involving content moderation and other rights affected in the environment of digital platforms.
The instrument was explicitly conceived as a complementary layer, not a substitute: it does not replace the platforms’ internal moderation and appeal systems, nor does it eliminate access to the courts or to arbitration where appropriate; it adds something the current ecosystem lacks, namely an independent, specialized and functionally neutral instance for the cases that survive internal review.

The functioning of the SMOD-CDD is built on a predominantly documentary and asynchronous procedure, a design choice that reflects the nature of the conflicts it addresses.
A case is submitted through the system’s online portal and undergoes a formal analysis of admissibility and requirements by the chamber’s Executive Secretariat. The respondent is then notified and given the opportunity to present a response, when applicable. An Expert is appointed with adequate experience in the subject matter, subject to a declaration of independence and impartiality. Next, the Expert analyzes the documents, may request additional information, and issues a reasoned pronouncement indicating the applicable solution, which is communicated to the parties and to the adhering platform.
That decision, under the terms of the adhesion instrument, is binding on the platform. The binding nature in this case is an essential point, because a review that could be ignored at will would be worthless as a governance tool. The pronouncement may determine, depending on the nature of the controversy, the removal or restoration of content or the cessation of a given personal-data processing practice; the mechanism does not award damages, does not imply automatic regulatory compliance, and does not shield the platform from civil liability.
Its scope is deliberately broad, mirroring the complexity of digital disputes. The system covers conflicts over the removal, maintenance, restriction or restoration of content; intellectual property and unfair competition, including trademark issues, counterfeiting and unauthorized use of protected assets; privacy and personal data protection; personality rights such as name, image and voice; and content or practices on marketplaces involving identifiable legal positions.
Access, however, is structured and disciplined: the mechanism presupposes the platform’s prior adhesion, formalized through an instrument with the CDD-ABPI, which integrates the system into the platform’s review policy and establishes the conditions for implementation of decisions. As a rule, use is appropriate once the platform’s internal moderation and appeal mechanisms have been exhausted and a controversy still subsists. Platforms may also refer complex cases directly. The SMOD-CDD thus operates as a second layer between internal moderation and the judiciary.
The design also dialogues openly with international experience: although the European model of certified out-of-court dispute settlement bodies under Article 21 of the DSA is not applicable in Brazil, it served as a reference for building an independent, specialized and accessible review mechanism, adapted to Brazilian law through the framework of Decree No. 12,975/2026 and the understandings consolidated by the Supreme Court.
The design of the mechanism points to advantages for adhering platforms. The mechanism documents qualified diligence, which is the kind of diligence that demonstrates effort that, under the interpretative framework of the Supreme Court’s Leading Cases, can distinguish a platform that acts responsibly from one that simply ignores what circulates on its servers. It also proves due process in moderation decisions.
Moreover, it reduces judicial exposure by channeling complex cases into a specialized forum with predictable cost and duration, instead of leaving them to the unpredictability of litigation. It shifts technical analysis to experts versed in trademark, privacy and personality-rights matters, protecting the platform from accusations of bias or favoritism through an independent decision-maker.
It even contributes to structured transparency, since anonymized case data can feed the annual transparency reports that the regulatory environment demands. The costs are defined in advance, under the applicable fee table, removing one of the most corrosive uncertainties of judicial proceedings.
The SMOD-CDD is an institutionally administered, fully online, second-layer review mechanism that combines content moderation, intellectual property, data protection and personality rights under one set of rules, reflecting the convergence of subjects found in digital disputes. Its distinguishing feature is the application of ODR to disputes arising under the liability framework set by the Supreme Court’s ruling.
With the SMOD-CDD, the CDD-ABPI offers platforms a path to document the diligence expected under the liability framework, and offers users and rights holders an accessible, specialized forum that is independent of the platform that removed their content.
The results of the mechanism will depend on platform adhesion and on the quality of its pronouncements.
—
Author: Mariana de Araújo M. Lima Di Pietro, and Cesar Peduti Filho, Peduti Advogados.
—
“If you want to learn more about this topic, contact the author or the managing partner, Dr. Cesar Peduti Filho.”
“Se quiser saber mais sobre este tema, contate o autor ou o Dr. Cesar Peduti Filho.”
