The lawsuit filed by trinamiX against Apple - Peduti Advogados Skip to content

The lawsuit filed by trinamiX against Apple

On September 3, 2026, trinamiX, a subsidiary of the German chemical company BASF, filed a lawsuit against Apple in the U.S. District Court in Midland, Texas. According to the complaint, as reported, Apple allegedly infringed patented facial authentication technology used in several iPhone and iPad models. The plaintiff seeks damages in an unspecified amount and an order stopping further infringement.

 

The devices named in the complaint include the iPhone 15, iPhone 16, iPhone 17 and iPad Pro. The reports also mention Apple’s sales between the fourth quarter of 2025 and the second quarter of 2026, which reached US$ 196.5 billion for iPhones and US$ 21.7 billion for iPads. Those figures refer to the total sales of each product line and do not indicate the amount that may be at issue in the case.

 

According to the reports, Apple did not immediately respond to requests for comment. These are allegations made by the plaintiff, and the reports do not mention any court decision on them.

 

The technology and the timeline described in the complaint

According to trinamiX, the company spent the past decade developing technology to address security flaws in conventional facial recognition systems, which can be bypassed with photographs, 3D-printed masks and silicone replicas. BASF states that the origins of trinamiX date back to 2010, when scientists researching organic solar cells made unexpected discoveries that led to the first prototypes of three-dimensional cameras. The subsidiary was created in 2014 as an independent entity to develop advanced 3D sensing and materials technologies and, according to the complaint, holds more than 800 granted or pending patents worldwide.

 

As to the timeline, the complaint states that Apple did not use the patented technology when it launched Face ID in 2017 with the iPhone X, but began to use it in later products. Under this account, the alleged infringement stems from the incorporation of the technology into models released after the original launch of the feature. The reports do not clarify which specific characteristics of the models named in the complaint are alleged to correspond to the patented technology.

 

How a patent infringement dispute is structured

In general terms, a patent grants its owner the right to prevent third parties from exploiting the protected invention in the territory where the patent was granted. The scope of that protection is defined by the patent claims. In an infringement action, the owner usually argues that the defendant’s product or process reproduces what those claims describe, which requires comparing the claim language with the accused product.

 

The defendant, in turn, may argue that its product falls outside the claims or challenge the validity of the patent. Depending on the jurisdiction and on the circumstances of the case, the outcome may include damages and an order to cease use, among other measures. In U.S. federal courts, these disputes generally begin with the filing of the complaint, followed by the defendant’s response, an exchange of evidence, the court’s interpretation of the disputed claims and, if the case proceeds, trial. The process can last for an extended period.

 

 

In this case, the reports do not detail the patent numbers, the claims invoked or Apple’s defense. The development of the case will therefore depend on the documents filed by the parties and on the court’s analysis.

 

Product updates and patent coverage

The timeline described in the complaint reflects a situation common in technology markets. Products evolve through successive models, and a feature introduced in a later version is examined on its own terms in light of the patents in force at that time, regardless of whether the earlier versions were affected.

 

Companies that develop or update products with security, biometric and sensing features commonly carry out freedom-to-operate analyses before launching new versions. It is also usual to monitor third-party patents and to manage their own portfolios, with filings in different jurisdictions. For patent owners, following the evolution of products on the market is a common practice in the administration of their rights.

 

Territoriality and the Brazilian perspective 

Patents are territorial, and this lawsuit concerns rights granted in the United States. In Brazil, protection is likewise limited to the national territory, depends on a patent being granted by the Brazilian Patent and Trademark Office (INPI) and is governed by the Brazilian Industrial Property Law. The existence of patents in other countries does not, by itself, create rights in Brazil.

 

For this reason, companies operating internationally usually examine, country by country, whether patents or applications cover the technology they intend to use or commercialize. Identifying corresponding patent families filed with INPI requires a specific search. The reports do not indicate whether trinamiX holds patents in Brazil or whether the same technology is the subject of proceedings in other countries.

 

The lawsuit filed by trinamiX against Apple on September 3, 2026 is based on allegations that will be examined by the U.S. judiciary. Whatever the outcome, the case brings together elements that recur in technology patent litigation, such as the delimitation of claims, the timeline of feature incorporation into products and the territorial nature of patent rights.

 

For companies in the technology sector, the case is a reminder that patent portfolios, product development and international strategy are connected topics. Following the developments of the case will help clarify how the court addresses each of these points.

 

—

 

Author: Andressa Vendramelli Natal, Thaís de Kassia R. Almeida Penteado and Cesar Peduti Filho, Peduti Advogados.

Source: Apple é processada nos EUA por patentes de reconhecimento facial em iPhones: https://g1.globo.com/tecnologia/noticia/2026/09/03/apple-e-processada-nos-eua-por-patentes-de-autenticacao-facial-em-iphones.ghtml

 

—

 

“If you want to learn more about this topic, contact the author or the managing partner, Dr. Cesar Peduti Filho.”

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp

Recommended articles

We are a specialised office in the area of intellectual property, entertainment and information technology. With 40 years of tradition, our performance results from the standards of excellence of its practice, expertise and knowledge of our team of professionals.
New Posts
Category

Contact:

R. Tenente Negrão, 140 – Itaim Bibi
São Paulo – SP | BRAZIL, 04530-030

+55 (11) 3706-0353

peduti@peduti.com.br